• Blog
  • NIGHT OF THE GOLDEN GHETTO
  • SLURRED
  • THE SHAPE-UP
  • My Bio
  • Contact
  • Acknowledgements
Andrew Hill

Racial Profiling and 'Hidden Figures' at Chicago's Posh Union League Club

1/3/2017

4 Comments

 
Octavia Spencer, Taraji P. Henson & Janelle Monae in "Hidden Figures"
"Intent," by Rene Romero Schuler (2013) at Chicago's Union League Club
Picture
There is a painting called Intent off the main lobby of Chicago's Union League Club, which I like a great deal. It's by Rene Romero Schuler, and it features a solitary, partially attenuated figure silhouetted against a mottled ivory background.  I've seen it several times, and it usually reminds me of Giacometti--the painted wall fragments from his legendary studio at Rue Hippolyte-Mandron or even Tall Figure and Walking Man.  But an unfortunate incident during my most recent three-day stay at ULC turned Schuler’s large square canvas into a symbol of race relations and a reminder of the uncertainties facing America during the presidency of Donald J. Trump.  

Twenty-three years ago, my brother was selected to head up a citywide charitable campaign whose meetings he could not attend because they were held at the exclusive members-only ULC.  A principal in the charitable organization said he could fix that and soon sponsored my brother for a membership in the prestigious club.  
 
How prestigious?  According to a 2013 article in Michigan Avenue magazine, the ULC is one of the top five private clubs in Chicago.  Founded in 1879, its membership includes prominent attorneys, physicians, insurance executives, politicians and other professionals.  As author Seth Putnam wrote, it was at the ULC that “Governor George Ryan announced a moratorium on the death penalty in Illinois.  In the President’s Room, where past club leaders are honored, Senator Dick Durban convinced a senator named Barack Obama to become a different sort of president.”  
 
A PROGRESSIVE HISTORY
The Union League Club has a history of championing causes such as racial equality, women’s suffrage, labor reform, and civil rights.  Depending on residency and age, membership runs between $150 and $750 per month after a not-terribly-exorbitant initiation fee.  Its art collection includes Claude Monet’s Apple Trees in Bloom, purchased in 1895 for a mere $500. There is a dress code. The rooms are well-appointed and modernized to include state-of-the-art flat-screen TV, Wi-Fi, and glass-doored marble-tiled showers.  It is lovely to stay there unless your suite is separated by a single locked door from rooms occupied by people you do not know.  Then your visit can be marred by the cooing of strangers or whatever chatter they may be engaged in.  Adjoining rooms are great when you have children in tow and  everyone belongs to the same party.  Otherwise, it's best to ask during registration for accommodations that will eliminate this issue a priori.
 
Because of my brother’s membership, I have been a guest at the ULC on several occasions during the past 20 years.  On this or that business-related trip, I have also enjoyed other top hotels near Millennial Park and elsewhere in Chicago.  But the ULC is my hands-down favorite. The art collection alone is worth the mild inconvenience of the club's dress code.  The staff has always been exceptionally courteous and kind.  And it feels good to know I'm able to experience the club's old-world charm because of my brother’s charitable work and professional success.  Membership has its privileges, as the saying goes, and it is my privilege to belong to a family that derives its current success from segregation-era parents who did the hard work of educating their children and laying the groundwork for largesse that now includes organizations like ULC. 

THE REGRETTABLE RACIAL INCIDENT
But during the holiday season at the end of 2016, a strangely uncharacteristic incident occurred under the venerable club's roof.  My sister and her husband, who were visiting from North Carolina as part of our family’s New Year’s celebration, were accused of smoking pot in their room.  The security team entered the suite while they were having breakfast in the club's dining room, determined that marijuana could be identified within its confines, and initiated a fine of $250 for violating the club’s no-smoking policy.
 
My sister does not smoke pot.  Neither does her husband.  A psychologist, she is Assistant Head of School at a private academy in North Carolina’s Research Triangle.  My brother-in-law has a Ph.D. in education and, in addition to a lucrative consulting practice, teaches at the college level.  Married for thirty-five years, they have raised two admirable children whom they educated at UNC, Guilford College, and Vanderbilt Law School.  The ULC security team checked only my sister’s room, the door to which was open while they were at breakfast because housekeeping was setting it right.  The security people claimed that marijuana could be smelled up and down the hallway and determined that my sister and brother-in-law’s room was the source of the offensive odor.  However, they did not find marijuana there.  Nor did they use any of the currently available digital technologies to measure the presence of smoke. Also, management could provide no answer as to why security had not checked elsewhere before accusing my sister and her husband of the crime. 
 
If you are a white American, you would be puzzled by this situation.  The investigative procedures were so faulty and the behavior so biased you would be forced to wonder how guests at a prestigious institution could be subjected to such a humiliation.  However, if you are African-American, even though you do not want to think it is so, you realize eventually that this is happening because you are black—as both my sister and brother-in-law happen to be. You notice that the housekeeping manager who instigated the marijuana complaint is white, and it becomes clear to you that she is emblematic of the peculiar nexus where things begin to break down in America, the snagged thread in our nation’s social fabric that threatens to pull the whole tapestry apart. 
 
The Union League Club is like the country we live in.  It has a set of values it tries to live by, but its reality is determined by individuals who make up the life within its walls.  One is tempted to shrug off the biases of a mid-level housekeeping manager for embarrassing guests of color.  But what If she had been a cop on the streets of any major city in America? How long would it be before she pulled a gun and sent one of us to an early grave because her inability to see beyond race led to a false and wholly improbable conclusion?
 
Eventually, a higher level of management was called in to investigate the situation, and the true source of the marijuana violation was found in a room down the hall from my sister and brother-in-law’s.  The club later apologized for the incident, offered to adjust their bill, and provided complimentary champagne when we returned from the movie we almost missed because of the incident—a screening, believe it or not, of Hidden Figures.
 
WITNESSING MY MOTHER'S STRUGGLE VIA THE MOVIE
If you haven't seen the film, I urge you to do so.  It's about the African-American women whose mathematical, computational, and engineering prowess contributed to NASA’s space program during a time when they could not even use the same bathrooms as whites. Performances by Octavia Spencer, Tarji P. Henson, Janelle Monae, Kevin Costner and Kirsten Dunst are credible and deeply moving.  We didn't select Hidden Figures because of what happened at ULC.  It was part of the day's prearranged itinerary, which in retrospect now seems to have been orchestrated by Jungian synchronicity. But after what can only be described as a racial incident in one of the top five private clubs in Chicago, the movie took on additional layers of meaning for us—making it not only a historical film about a bygone era but a cautionary tale for post-Election 2016 America.  
 
My siblings and I noticed a striking similarity between our mother's struggle to become the first African-American supervisor at Macy's Department Store in the 1960's and Octavia Spencer's portrayal of Dorothy Vaughan’s effort to achieve a comparable promotion at NASA.  Like Spencer's character, my Mom led a department of mostly African-American women whom she inspired to attend college and apply for other opportunities within the organization. She adjusted their schedules so they could attend classes and inspired them to represent their African-American heritage in the most progressive and forward-looking manner possible, reminding them as members of her generation often felt compelled to do, that all eyes would be on them because of their race.  And it was up to them to represent our people in the best possible light. 

THE RATIONALE THAT PREVENTS PEOPLE FROM SEEING THE TRUTH
Years after my mother's retirement, when I drove her to the supermarket or the dollar store, or to Home Depot for the annuals she planted every Spring, I was amazed to find her one-time clericals stopping to thank her for what she contributed to their lives when they were fresh out of high school and uncertain about what to do with themselves.  My mother would not be able to invoke racial pride as a motivational tool in today's corporate world.  But there was one aspect of Hidden Figures that rings as true today as it was in 1962.  That's the moment when, after repeatedly side-stepping or rebuffing Spencer's requests for a deserved promotion, the blonde manager played by Kirsten Dunst claims that she has nothing against Spencer. 

Vivian Mitchell: Despite what you may think, I have nothing against y'all.

Dorothy Vaughan: I know.  I know you probably believe that.

The same could be said of voters who helped put Trump in the White House. It was because of his tax plan, they will tell you. Or because he'll restore manufacturing jobs and rebuild the country's infrastructure.  Never mind that his statements about race made him the candidate of the Ku Klux Klan.  Or that he claimed a Hispanic judge was not competent to hear a case because of his race.  Or that everything about the man’s candidacy seemed to fly in the face of America’s core values.  That's not why I voted for him, these people will tell you.  It's because of his straightforward talk and economic policies.  

 "I know you probably believe that."
 
When we returned to the Union League Club after the movie, everything was hunky dory. The champagne was delicious, and whenever we were at table, we felt reassured at every turn by the staff's understated but ramped-up attention that the organization wanted to redress the earlier incident and lay it to rest.  I should mention that my family's core values do not include looking for reasons to feel aggrieved by perceived racial injustice.  But when racism does occur, we are willing to look it in the eye and call it what it is.  In place of the ramped-up attention, we would have preferred to move forward with our holiday without incident.  Each of us is an established professional.  We don't invent or invite racial difficulties in order to validate our existence.  We're far too busy living our lives and doing the work that's helped make us secure.
 
The intent of the Union League Club as an organization was clear.  When it recognized that a mistake had been made, it moved to rectify the situation.  What I say here is not meant to cast aspersions on ULC. But here's the thing: if a humiliating racial incident set in motion by staff with insufficient diversity training could occur at a club known for its record on racial and gender equality, what is happening elsewhere in the country where once-closeted racists may now feel empowered by the ascent of a candidate who catered to them?

There are no colored bathrooms at the ULC like the ones featured significantly in Hidden Figures.  They have disappeared everywhere in America since the 1964 Civil Rights Act made them illegal.  But what is racial profiling if not an aspect of the Jim Crow toilet-seat mentality that blacks are ipso facto carriers of the undesirable be it an imaginary disease or the smoking of marijuana in one's hotel room?

There are people of color in this country who do not think this situation applies to them.  They seek to "transcend race," presuming  that wealth and membership in exclusive private clubs will inoculate them from racism.  To these folks I can only say,  "I know you probably believe that."

WHY DO THESE INCIDENTS SEEM TO OCCUR MORE OFTEN NOW?
We have already seen random news reports of what appears to be an increase in racially motivated bullying since the presidential election.  As NPR reported, Hispanic children in North Carolina have been taunted by white classmates who accused them of being undocumented aliens, claiming they would soon be deported.  There is also the widely publicized case of African-American TV commentator Angela Rye, who was aggressively frisked by a white TSA agent of the same gender, which was captured on cell-phone video at Rye's request and posted on social media.  Would these things have happened if the election had turned out differently?  Are they receiving increased attention now because the "liberal media" is trying to make a point at the expense of the president-elect?  Or has he given tacit permission through his rhetoric and tone that these things are okay? 

One of the many anonymous trolls that appear when incidents like Rye's go viral commented that it occurred because Rye regards herself as a "victim," adding that this was why she wanted the incident to be captured on video - to prove and document her victimhood.  The taunt raises an interesting question.  To what degree does unconscious intent influence what happens to us in the lived-out world?  Did Donald Trump become president of the United States because he internalized the lessons of his one-time pastor, Norman Vincent Peale, and strongly believed he would win the election no matter what?  Does Angela Rye harbor feelings of victimhood that subvert her outward success?  Does she feel guilty about her achievements and secretly wish for opportunities to be more like the heroes of the Civil Rights Movement?

I do not know these people, and I do not know the answers to these deeply personal questions.  But I do believe that we must remain vigilant in our thought lives.  That we must not allow ourselves to fall in love with and internalize the negative.  We must be able to look at it when it arises, but we must not entertain it or hold onto it in our hearts.  This is our daily, if not hourly task.  To remember that we are co-creators of our realities and must do the necessary internal and external work to bring about lives that reflect our inner values.  To create the interior math that will establish the go/no-go point in the trajectory of our lives.  To borrow once again from Hidden Figures, this is how each of us can put a man on the moon. 

It is a question of intent.

Additional Reading: See The Rage of a Privileged Class: Why Are Middle-Class Blacks Angry? Why Should America Care? by Ellis Cose, 2009.  Also: The End of Anger: A New Generation's Take on Race and Rage, also by Ellis Cose.
Picture
Picture
4 Comments
Kiley Fuchs link
1/7/2017 11:46:33 pm

Thank you for this. It provided me a perspective that I don't access enough. It helped me more clearly articulate my anger and concerns with those who 'looked past' the blatant racism and hatemongering of Trump. I will definitely take note of the recommended reading.

Reply
Andrew
1/8/2017 05:06:23 pm

Thank you for reading and commenting. I'm glad you found ideas here that helped crystallize your own feelings. Anger, as you may know, is a secondary emotion, which covers the primary emotion of fear. Those of us who don't like what we see in the political sphere must be careful, I feel, not to let the fear-mongering obstruct our own "better angels." We need those angels within ourselves now more than ever.
Best wishes,
Andrew

Reply
Kiley Fuchs
1/9/2017 01:55:43 am

Thank you for the thoughtful and encouraging response. I am fearful of the anger I carry which was revealed to me by last year's events. I recognize that I simultaneously grieve and feel guilt for my naivety and temporary loss of faith in human goodness. I feel blessed to have discovered your work and Twitter. It continues to offer me guidance, reassurance, and wisdom while I work to challenge myself and my beliefs for better. I aspire through difficult introspective work and time to be the same beacon of light for others that you have been to many. Thank you again Mr. Hill. I'm listening.

Reply
Andrew
1/10/2017 01:32:46 am

What you've written here makes me feel hopeful about humanity. You remind me of the premise behind Joseph Campbell's "The Hero with a Thousand Faces." Within each generation there is a universal life force, manifest in myriad ways, which wants us to succeed, to realize and become our truest and best selves. Those who embrace and embody this spirit are called heroes, but they are wise enough to know they are but conduits for this higher energy. I heard Campbell lecture before he died, and his books have been extremely helpful to me. I highly recommend his work on the Power of Myth and also Carl Jung's "Man and His Symbols," which provides a lay man's guide to his ideas on the importance of dreams, synchronicity, the collective unconscious, and so much more. I don't know if these will be as helpful to you as they were to me. You may find through your reading and searching some other teachers who are right for your particular path. The good news is this: What you are seeking already exists within you. Dreams, if you learn to decipher and heed their guidance, will show you the way. Your desire to be the light you seek will help keep you motivated. Keep the fire burning bright by reading. Not just by extracting information in a hit-and run manner but by giving yourself over to the pleasure of extended concentration that reading requires. The payoff is worth the investment of time and energy. If nothing else, it frees your imagination and opens your mind. But it can also make you more tolerant, understanding, and forgiving of others. I believe that people are basically good, and your comments remind me that despite the confusion and malice so readily apparent in the outer world, the human race will always give rise to people like you who strive toward the light. Be gentle and forgiving of yourself. It may take awhile to reach your goal. So throw in a little patience too. Thanks again for your kind comments about my scribblings. Keep the faith!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    If you’re reading this website, think of me as a troubadour standing on the street corner, strumming a guitar and singing a few songs.  Not everyone who comes this way is able to make contribution.  But if you’re one of the passers-by who can, then feel free to drop a little spare change in my hat by clicking either the Donate or the Become a Patron button below.  Thank you!
    Become a Patron!
    SHOPPING
    SUBSCRIBE
    SUBSCRIBE
    To be notified of new posts to this blog

    Archives

    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    January 2016
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013


    OTHER GREAT WEB SITES & BLOGS I ENJOY:
    Rhys Tranter
    Pam Perkins
    Ann Cavitt Fisher
    Brain Pickings - Maria Popova

    Categories

    All
    Andre Rieu
    Andrew Stanton
    Ang Lee
    Anne Hathaway
    Anne Rice
    Annie Leibovitz
    Ann Patchett
    A&P
    A Portrait Of The Artist As A Young Man
    Archibald MacLeish
    Aretha Franklin
    Armistead Maupin
    Art
    Arthur Miller
    Art Tatum
    Arturo Sandoval
    Auguste Rodin
    Avery Brooks
    Basquiat
    Ben Kingsley
    Betty White
    Bibi Andersson
    Bill Murray
    Billy Taylor
    Blanche Dubois
    Blind Willie
    Blue Danube
    Bobby Seale
    Bonjour
    Breakfast At Tiffany's
    Bruce Springsteen
    Buried Child
    Burt Lancaster
    Calista Flockhart
    Candice Bergen
    Carmen
    Carnal Knowledge
    Carol Burnett
    Carrie
    Cate Blanchett
    Catherine Deneuve
    Celia Cruz
    Charles Ives
    Charles McGrath
    Charles Schultz
    Charleton Heston
    Charlie Rose
    Charlotte Bronte
    Cherry Jones
    Chicago
    Civil Rights
    Clark Terry
    Coco Chanel
    Coffee Shop Prank
    Cointelpro
    Commentary
    Crossroads
    Current Events
    Daniel Ellsberg
    Dashiell Hammett
    Dave Brubeck
    David Letterman
    Death In Venice
    Death Penalty
    Deborah Treisman
    Deepak Chopra
    Dennis Haysbert
    Dennis Quaid
    Derek Jacobi
    Devil Wears Prada
    D.H. Lawrence
    Diana Krall
    Dick Cavett
    Dizzy Gillespie
    Donald Trump Tape
    Donny Hathaway
    Dostoevsky
    Downton Abbey
    Downton Sixbey
    Dr. Jekyll And Mr. Hyde
    Dumbledore
    Dune
    Dymaxion Car
    Earl Lloyd
    Edward Fox
    Edward Snowden
    Eileen Atkins
    Elie Wiesel
    Eliot Preludes
    Emily's Monologue From Our Town
    Emma Stone
    Esperanza Spalding
    Ethel Waters
    Eugene Ionesco
    Eugene O'Neill
    Famous Birthdays
    Far From Heaven
    Fifty Shades Of Grey
    Film Reviews
    Firing Line
    First Kiss
    Frank Herbert
    Franz Liszt
    Fred Astaire
    George Bernard Shaw
    George Foreman
    George Gershwin
    Georges Bizet
    Georges Braques
    George S. Kaufman
    Georges Seurat
    Ghost
    Gilda Radner
    Gloria Steinem
    Gone With The Wind
    Gunfight At Ok Corral
    Hamlet
    Happy Birthday Mr. President
    Harriet Beecher Stowe
    Harrison Ford
    Harry Chapin
    H. G. Wells
    Historical Figures & Events
    Horowitz
    Howard Rollins
    Ideas Worth Thinking About
    If You Leave Me Now
    Imagine
    In Cold Blood
    Ingmar Bergman
    Innocence Project
    Interview With A Vampire
    Jack Nicholson
    Jack Paar
    James Joyce
    Jane Eyre
    Jazz Messengers
    Jean Rhys
    Jean Seberg
    Jelly Roll Morton
    Jfk
    Jimmy Fallon
    Joe Louis
    Johann Strauss
    John Barrymore
    John Brown
    John Coltrane
    John Le Carre
    John Lennon
    John Malkovich
    Johnny Carson
    John Updike
    Joseph Campbell
    Joseph Conrad
    Jr.
    Judith Jamison
    Julian Fellowes
    Julianne Moore
    Julian Schnabel
    Julie Harris
    Katherine Hepburn
    Kathleen Battle
    Katy Perry
    Keith Jarrett
    Kierkegaard
    Krishnamurti
    Kublai Khan
    Kurt Vonnegut
    Lady Chatterley
    La Negra Tiene Tumbao
    Laura Esquivel
    Leap Of Faith
    Lee Strasberg
    Leonard Bernstein
    Leonardo Dicaprio
    Letter From A Birmingham Jail
    Like Water For Chocolate
    Lorne Michaels
    Louis Auchincloss
    Madame Bovary
    Mahalia Jackson
    Malcom X
    Maria Callas
    Marilyn Monroe
    Marissa Berenson
    Martin Luther King
    Martin Scorcese
    Mary Wells
    Medea
    Melba Moore
    Michael Crichton
    Michael Gambon
    Michael Jackson
    Michelangelo
    Mike Nichols
    Modernism
    Moms Mabley
    Montgomery Clift
    Moss Hart
    Muhammad Ali
    Murphy Brown
    Muses & Music
    Music
    My Dinner With Andre
    Nathaniel West
    Nat King Cole
    Nelson Mandela
    New Yorker Fiction Podcast
    Nietzsche
    Night At The Opera
    Night In Tunisia
    Orson Welles
    Oscar Wilde
    Oscar Wilde Released
    Otto Preminger
    Our Town
    Pappano
    Pascal Ferran
    Pat Conroy
    Paul Desmond
    Paul Simon
    Peanuts
    Penelope Ann Miller
    Penny Marshall
    Peter Jackson
    Pete Seeger
    Picasso
    Pier Paolo Pasolini
    Playing With Dynamite
    Pope John Xxiii
    Presidential Politics
    Prufrock
    P-word
    Race
    Rachel Mcadams
    Rape Culture
    Ray Charles
    Rex Harrison
    Rfk
    Rhinoceros
    Richard Dreyfus
    Rimbaud
    Robert Johnson
    Robert Kennedy
    Robert Louis Stevenson
    Roger Angell
    Rumble In The Jungle
    Ryan O'Neal
    Sacco & Vanzetti
    Saint Joan
    Sally Hemings
    Sam Shepard
    Samuel Taylor Coleridge
    Sartre
    Saturday Night Live
    Scarlett O'Hara
    Scopes Monkey Trial
    Sense And Sensibility
    Serena Williams
    Sexual Assault
    Sherlock Holmes
    Shirley Jackson
    Sissy Spacek
    Sister Act
    Sistine Chapel
    Spencer Tracy
    Spengler's Decline Of The West
    Stanley Kubrick
    Stephen Colbert
    Steve Martin
    Stevie Wonder
    St. Louis Blues
    Tagore
    Tales Of The City
    Tammy Wynette
    Terry Mcmillan
    Thackeray
    The Great Beauty
    The Great Santini
    The Leopard
    The Pointer Sisters
    The Singing Detective
    The Unanswered Question
    The Waste Land
    Thomas Jefferson
    Thoreau
    Timothy Leary
    Tina Turner
    Todd Haynes
    Tom Hanks
    Tommy Lee Jones
    To Seek A Newer World
    Tristesse
    True West
    Truman Capote
    Truth & Beauty
    T. S. Eliot
    T.S. Eliot
    Tyrone Power
    Uncle Tom's Cabin
    Unconditionally
    Virgil
    Visconti
    Vivien Leigh
    Waiting To Exhale
    Wally Shawn
    Walter Cronkite
    War Of The Worlds
    W.C. Handy
    What's Love Got To Do With It
    Whitney Houston
    Whoopi Goldberg
    Wide Sargasso Sea
    Willa Cather
    William Buckley
    William Faulkner
    William Shatner
    Women's Rights
    Woody Allen
    Writers & Writing
    W.S. Gilbert
    Wynton Marsalis
    Yogi Berra
    You Make Me Feel
    Yul Brenner

    RSS Feed

@2016 ANDREW HILL  |  ALL RIGHTS RESERVED  |  www.andrewhillbooks.com  |  CONTACT  |  PURCHASE BOOKS 
  • Blog
  • NIGHT OF THE GOLDEN GHETTO
  • SLURRED
  • THE SHAPE-UP
  • My Bio
  • Contact
  • Acknowledgements
✕